Creative Commons license icon

Copyrighting your Muck Characters?

0
Your rating: None

Often I see on people's websites, and on popular art galleries pictures of their or others muck or role-play characters. And in most instances they are followed by descriptions similar to 'FluffyWuffieBunniekins Copyright Me, Art Copyright Some Guy I Met Online!!!'. Well, sometimes with real names. But do most people understand what copyright means? Lets answer a few common questions...
Can I copyright my character?
The short answer is - No.
The longer answer is - Well, partially, but it has never actually been fully and legally tested and is unlikely to stand up in court.
The root of this problem is that Copyright applies to the Ideas or Expression that have been fixed in a medium. A picture of a character can be copyrighted. A text description of that character can be copyrighted. The concept of that character? Debatable.
You could argue that use of a character in a different work is in effect a derivative use of the description or pictorial representation of the character. But derivation is always considered with weight given to the proportionality of use. Use of one character based on a short text description in, say, a comic book with multiple characters may not pass as a derived work.
Use of a large amount of characters from one work in another however, would be a derivation of the original. For example, you wouldn't be able to make your own comic book using the Belle's of St Trinians... But having one character from St Trinians show up in your work... Maybe.
In essence, there is no easy way to copyright a character... But, you can trademark a character's name and likeness. For instance, Terry Pratchett and Rhiana Pratchett hold trademarks on the name and likeness of 'The Luggage', which can be used to halt any use of the character for marketing or use in commercial ventures such as published books. However, this does not grant them right to control mention of 'The Luggage' in things such as this article for instance.

If I pay someone for a commission, I partially own the copyright as a Work For Hire right?
The short answer - No.
The longer answer - Hell No.
The longer longer answer - No, but maybe yes in some cases.
Lets make this specific, just paying someone to create an art work or text does not transfer ownership of the copyright. One of the following conditions must have been met before any transfer or partial ownership :-
1) Both the commissioner and creator have a signed agreement to transfer copyright ownership.
2) The commissioner has provided some of the work towards the creation of the art or text. For example, an exact specification of the drawing - 'The lion`s head tilts to the left slightly. The water in the glass is fizzing, and dripping over the sides...'
3) The artist has derived the work from another. Remember, only original creation acquires copyright. So, in this case neither of you owns the copyright. If you pay someone to write you Sonic fanfic, then you don't magically make it more copyrightable.

Hold on, I paid for the commission, but you say I cant use it in my publication and publish it on my website?
The short answer - Got it in one.
The longer answer - See above. Unless specifically attributed the rights are withheld.
Unless you have specifically been granted permission, or have already acquired copyright as above, you do not have the right to reproduce a work bought on commission. The artist reserves this right unless granted to you. In fact, you cant stop the artist then going and selling thousands of copies of your commission to other people if they want. Remember, in buying a commission you are purchasing the artists time to produce one single work. Anything else needs further agreement from the creator.

To Summarise
You can copyright a text description of your character, but you can not copyright the concept of your character. If you pay an artist to draw your character, you do not automatically gain the copyright to that drawing. The artist is within their rights to republish and sell prints of that drawing if they wish and have not made any other agreement with you.

References
http://www.templetons.com/brad/copymyths.htm
http://www.ivanhoffman.com/characters.html
http://www.anweb.co.uk/l_04_d3/d3b01.htm

Comments

Your rating: None

I didn't copyright my character... I patented the idea!

Everyone who plays a bipedal animal with the capability of speech owes me royalties.

Your rating: None

Strange... I was logged in when I sub'ed this, but it dosnt have my name on it.

Your rating: None

Sometimes it'll log people out when they're previewing.

Melissa "MelSkunk" Drake

Your rating: None

Has this been reported as a bug to the upstream maintainers?

Your rating: None

You'd have to ask Aureth. I think it's actually a browser issue, as I used to have this problem before the recient upload, and sometimes still do when using Mozilla.
But I don't know jack

Melissa "MelSkunk" Drake

Your rating: None

I've just had it pointed out that I've missed an important reference out - http://www.loc.gov/copyright/circs/circ09.pdf - which details work for hire restrictions on claiming copyright.

Your rating: None

Also - http://www.rexx.com/~jaguar/copyright.html - which was one of my primary resources and I'm silly for forgeting to cite it.

Your rating: None

Legalities aside, I always thought it at least courteous to mention when a character you're/I'm drawing is not of the artist's own creation. Also it's best to get permission before drawing someone else's character.

Sure, it may not stand up in court, but then neither would holding the door for someone as opposed to slamming it in that individual's face. It's courtesy as opposed to law.

Which I find makes more sense if you're a novice artist (such as myself) who doesn't make any money at all--there's no gain or loss to anyone, why should anything but plain 'being nice' enter into the event?

Just my US$0.02.

Smile! The world could use another happy person.

Your rating: None

So we can't copyright the character itself very easily.

But it is possible to trademark the name and likeness of the character.

So how does one go about getting a character's name and likeness trademarked?

Your rating: None

So we can't copyright the character itself very easily.
But it is possible to trademark the name and likeness of the character.
So how does one go about getting a character's name and likeness trademarked?

My understanding is that this is in the "pay lawyers and the government bureaucracy lots of money" category. It could be worse. You could be trying to patent something.

Your rating: None Average: 5 (1 vote)

So, I can draw a picture of a cat taur, and as long as I don't call it a 'Chakat' Bernard Doove can't come running after me with a stick claiming copyright violation?
What about if I draw a wolf named Jen; can some other artist who also has a wolf character named Jen come after me claiming I copied them, even though the species wolf and the name Jen are both very common?

Your rating: None Average: 5 (1 vote)

This article is misleading. Sorry to frankenthread, but I felt it might be helpful to clarify things here.

The internet is a copyrightable medium, meaning that if you have a defined character that is creatively distinct from another character, you can claim copyright. Artists hired for commissions do not suddenly and miraculously command any copyright for the characters they draw, but it is generally viewed as mutual courtesy for an artist to mention the creator of the character, as well as that creator to understand that the artist sees benefit from being able to post the piece and potentially include it in portfolios or even published art collections. With the case of a published art collection for profit, however, the artist will probably want to check with anyone who has a character included in the art he intends to include.

Most major copyright concerns revolve around the questions of whether or not someone intends to profit from it, and if that person's work is detrimental to the original copyright holder's ability to benefit from his own creation.

Artists build their careers by showing other people what they can do, so it's important to most artists to be able to post their work freely. If you hire an artist to do work for you but deny them this ability, you may not be able to hire them again.

Copyright tends to be something that is more trouble than it is worth to take to suit, but it's best if people behave with courtesy and consideration for others and their creations.

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <img> <b> <i> <s> <blockquote> <ul> <ol> <li> <table> <tr> <td> <th> <sub> <sup> <object> <embed> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <dl> <dt> <dd> <param> <center> <strong> <q> <cite> <code> <em>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This test is to prevent automated spam submissions.