Creative Commons license icon

Three comic book reviews: Pull List #25 ('The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl')

Edited by earthfurst as of Thu 6 Aug 2015 - 01:15
Your rating: None Average: 2 (4 votes)

The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl #1I've probably made it fairly clear in past Pull Lists, but just in case I haven't, Squirrel Girl is my favorite superhero. For those of you unfamiliar with the character, Doreen Green is a Marvel mutant with the ability to talk to squirrels, as well as squirrel like agility, plus a squirrel tail. Together with her squirrel sidekick, Tippy Toe, she fights crime as Squirrel Girl. Very well. At risk of sounding like a hipster, I liked Squirrel Girl before Squirrel Girl was cool. Of course, Squirrel Girl is cool because she is not cool (which also sounds super hipster-y), but my love for the character is not ironic.

I like her because she is a genuine superhero; she both has superpowers and acts heroically, but more importantly, she also likes being a superhero. She has fun being a superhero. If she doesn't take, say, an encounter with Doctor Doom seriously, it's not because she herself sees the ridiculousness of the situation. She doesn't see fights with supervillains as something to worry about; she's a superhero. She is supposed to fight supervillains; and she wants to fight supervillains. On a meta-level (and though she doesn't quite go to, say, Deadpool's textual awareness level, like most "humorous" Marvel characters, she has her medium aware moments), she believes that she will win any fight with a supervillain because she is a superhero, and superheroes always win in the superhero stories she reads; therefore, by choosing to be a superhero, she chooses to win. It is not "realistic" that she should, say, beat Doctor Doom with squirrels, but, seeing as how she isn't real, reality does not concern her.

This is why she is such a divisive character; a certain sort of comic book fan believes that comic book superheroes can only be taken seriously if it is presented "realistically." This viewpoint has been the default comic book fan view for decades now, to the point where a character who regularly and unequivocally wins fights with supervillains, and doesn't angst about it, stands out like a sore thumb, and is therefore a breath of fresh air, especially if your personal preference (like mine) is Guardians of the Galaxy over Watchmen. This is not to say a comic book that deals with the consequences of superheroics is bad; it's to say that a comic book that deals with the consequences of superheroics isn't automatically good. And comic books that don't aren't automatically bad. Or for that matter, that "realism" and "explores consequences" are mutually exclusive.

So, anyway, Squirrel Girl has her own comic book now, and it's awesome. Here's a review of the first three issues.

The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl #1

This issue starts up the new status quo for the character; despite this being her first ongoing title, she's already had two previous regular beats, first as a member of the Great Lakes Avengers, then as Danielle Cage's nanny in The New Avengers. Now that those jobs are over, she has decided squatting in an attic, though appropriately squirrelly, is kind of lame, even if it is the attic to the Avenger's Mansion. Time for college, then!

Brian Michael Bendis wrote Squirrel Girl in New Avengers, and it was ... actually kind of icky. Okay, it was nice she got to beat up Wolverine and all, but scenes in which she flirts with Daredevil ... flirting isn't actually the word. Sexually propositions is more accurate. "Squirrel Girl sexually propositions Daredevil (while holding a baby)." is not a sentence that should exist, and now it does. Bendis never got the character; thank God Ryan North is writing this. Here, when she meets an attractive fellow student, her flirting is awkward, as befits a character who is trying to keep her superhero identity secret, literally, because that's what superheroes do in comics. In other words, it acknowledges that while Squirrel Girl is a young adult, and therefore capable of "romance", it also spares us from a sexually aggressive Squirrel Girl making Daredevil very uncomfortable. Fans who follow the character have seen her first kiss; it was cute (and a little awkward). Cute (and a little awkward) is Squirrel Girl's thing, from a "romantic" perspective.

Since winning fights well above her pay grade is her thing, from a "superhero" perspective, she wins a fight with Kraven the Hunter, which also sets up the status quo for how these fights are going to work, for the most part. The fight establishes that she is a physically capable fighter, but that her real weapon is her clever use of her squirrelly powers, as well as her ability to understand and empathize with her enemies. She may be the only superhero who fights win/win.

The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl #2The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl #2

One of the things Ryan North brings to The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl is that he is actually a humorous writer. He is best known for the webcomic Dinosaur Comics; that's the one where the same three clip art dinosaurs in the same positions have new dialogue every strip (seems like a better idea than something actually executed, personally). Bendis, obviously, never got the character; Will Murray seemed to just be throwing stuff against a wall to see what stuck when he created the character, and Dan Slott, who reintroduced the character, seemed to waver a bit as to whether you were supposed to laugh with or at Squirrel Girl (and was prone to use her as a mouthpiece when it was "laugh with"). Outside of Fabian Nicieza, who did the aforementioned one-off "First Kiss" story, North is the first writer that seems to be coming at Squirrel Girl from a place of affection.

Erica Henderson is also the first female artist to tackle the character, and that does position the comic in a much more feminist frame. For instance, Dan Slott, in one of his "Squirrel Girl as a mouthpiece" moments, had her complain about the fetishization of female superheroes in comic books ("That poor lady! All her insides have been squished into her chest!"), but the impact is lessened a bit when she looks like this. Henderson's new design makes her much more human; it also brings back many elements of Steve "Frikkin'" Ditko's original design which have been underplayed as they distract from the usual comic book embodiment of femininity (i.e. hot). In other words, I really like it. Also, from a furry perspective, how can I complain about her decision to go with fake animal ears?
The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl #3
In this issue, Doreen and her new roommate attend a college club fair, but are interrupted by Tippy Toe, who informs Squirrel Girl that none other than Galactus is headed for Earth. The scene where Tippy tries to dramatically jump through a pane of glass only to harmlessly bounce off in order to gain Doreen's attention is surprisingly funny, partially because of how it isn't played dramatically, as it would in a lot of comedies. It's only after the fact that we learn Tippy imagined it would look cool. It's actually a fairly subtle joke, which is nice.

The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl #3

In this third issue, Squirrel Girl must make it to the moon to stop Galactus. Spaceflight, not being a very squirrely power, is not one of Squirrel Girl's skills. So, she decides to "borrow" some of Iron Man's unused suits.

In this issue, I'm going to say that it does a good job of explaining Iron Man and Squirrel Girl's relationship, and why Squirrel Girl is able to "borrow" the suits in the first place. However, I may not be the best person to gauge this, as I already know the history between Iron Man and Squirrel Girl; the book does reward people who know Squirrel Girl's history in the comics. However, seeing as how she is a "cult" character, anyone who is reading the first couple of issues of Squirrel Girl, who is essentially a character with a handful of stories, no upcoming movie, and no previous headlining of a comic book one-shot, never mind ongoing series, is already a part of that "cult", and gets the otherwise obscure references (not that there are a lot; just enough). It's obvious both the two major creatives on the book are fans of the character.

So, yes, I may also be not the right person to gauge a Squirrel Girl book because I really like Squirrel Girl books. But, in counter, I'd say that just means I have high expectations, and to say that this series has so far not just met those expectations, but exceeded them, is pretty high praise.


Your rating: None Average: 3 (4 votes)

The problem is not "realism" per se, but rather the adolescent conception of "realism" as simply violence, nihilism, pretentiousness and misogyny. In short, it's a conception of "realism" promoted by the sort of people who think it's profound to call traffic cops "fascists", or who regard Christian Bale's gravelly Batman-voice as the epitome of screen acting. (Why? Because it's... "realistic".)

Your rating: None Average: 1.5 (4 votes)

I think there's two flaws; one, what you're describing, in which what is described as "realism" isn't actually very realistic, and, two, when this form of "realism" is assumed to be superior to any other form of storytelling, especially humorous or "fantastic" modes of storytelling.

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <img> <b> <i> <s> <blockquote> <ul> <ol> <li> <table> <tr> <td> <th> <sub> <sup> <object> <embed> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <dl> <dt> <dd> <param> <center> <strong> <q> <cite> <code> <em>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

This test is to prevent automated spam submissions.
Leave empty.